DUO Education:  The Path to a Brighter Future
A Subsidiary of DUO Dynamics
email: duo_dynamics (at) yahoo (dot) com
  • DUO Education
    • About
    • Contact Me
    • New on DUO Education
    • Classes
  • Blogs and Services
    • DUO Education Learning Blog >
      • Jam with Jodi Monthly Newsletter Gallery
    • I Wonder…
    • Story Starters and Writing Prompts >
      • Story Starters and Writing Prompts Gallery
    • Online Tutoring Services
    • The Storyteller's Tale Webinar
    • The Game Room
    • Educational Discussions >
      • The Discussions Page
  • Books, Activity Pages, and Other Educational Products
    • Books by Jodi Desautels >
      • Activity Sheets to go with Books Written by Jodi Desautels
    • Sample Educational Activity Sheets >
      • Day 100 Activity Sheets
    • Educational Posters
    • Sample Binder Covers

The Difference Between Teaching People What to Think and Teaching People How to Think

4/3/2013

1 Comment

 
"And what is a good citizen?  Simply one who never says, does or thinks anything that is unusual.  Schools are maintained in order to bring this uniformity up to the highest possible point.  A school is a hopper into which children are heaved while they are still young and tender; therein they are pressed into certain standard shapes and covered from head to heels with official rubber-stamps."  ~H.L. Mencken
"Nature made us individuals, as she did the flowers and the pebbles; but we are afraid to be peculiar, and so our society resembles a bag of marbles, or a string of mold candles.  Why should we all dress after the same fashion?  The frost never paints my windows twice alike."  ~Lydia Maria Child
"I respect faith, but doubt is what gets you an education."  ~Wilson Mizner
"Those who stand for nothing fall for anything."  ~Alexander Hamilton
     Today, I have been thinking about the difference between teaching people what to think and teaching people how to think.  I hope that the quotes above help to get you in the mood for thinking about that also.  

     Consider this:  There are two students.  One does everything he is told.  He doesn't question authority in any way, gets wonderful grades, and is a pleasant student.  The other student gets okay grades but not so good and is always asking questions.  The teacher is constantly telling him to quiet down and focus.  Which is the better student?  Most people might think that the first student was the best student.  He had better grades and didn't challenge authority.  Yet, that is not the definition of student here.  Dictionary.com http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/student?s=t defines "student" as 1. a person formally engaged in learning, especially one enrolledin a school or college; pupil: a student at Yale.  2.any person who studies, investigates, or examines thoughtfully:a student of human nature.  The answer might be that we can't tell based on the limited information.  Or, it could be... the second, because he is the one who asks questions and seems to have the desire to think for himself.  The second student "investigates" whereas the first does not.
     Do you remember getting the "because I said so" response when you asked "why?"  I think we all have got that response at one time or another.  It is quick and easy and meant to end conversation.  It also teaches us not to ask questions and not to think for ourselves.
     I can remember that and other "think this way instead of for yourself" answers.  How about, "Well, it is in the textbook, so it has to be right."  We weren't taught that textbooks were made by humans and humans can make mistakes.  I am not saying that all textbooks are wrong or should not be trusted.  I am just saying that if you believe something else, you may not be wrong.  Look into it further.  You could be right.  Explore and learn.  You don't have to put all your faith into the textbook.  It is good to think and learn for yourself.  You don't need to be a conformist.   
     Gwen Dewar wrote a thoughtful and thought-provoking article for Parenting Science on the subject of teaching children to think or dumbing them down.  Follow this link http://www.parentingscience.com/critical-thinking-in-children.html to read the article.  It was written a few years ago, but is not out dated.  Her thoughts still ring true today.  

     Let's consider this old Chinese proverb:  “Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day. Teach a man how to fish and you feed him for a lifetime.” ― Chinese Proverb   The same is true for thinking and learning.  See how it looks if you change the words a bit.  Give a man 'what to think' and you will teach him for a day.  Teach a man 'how to think' and you teach him for a lifetime.  What do you think?  
     So, now that we want to teach people how to think for themselves instead of what to think... how do we do it?  Well, there are books that answer this question.  I haven't read it and can't attest to the effectiveness but this one titled "Teach Your Kids to Think: Simple Tools You Can Use Every Day" http://www.thinkparenting.com/teach-your-kids-to-think.html by Maria Chesley Fisk might help.
     Here is an example of a teacher that seems to teach students how to think instead of what to think.  http://www.deccanherald.com/content/299567/teaching-kids-think-creatively.html  I hope you will check out the link and ponder the ways of this teacher.
     Questioning is a large part of the answer!  Consider how we are squelched from wanting to learn or for thinking from ourselves when we are told, "because I said so." We are first disappointed to hear the answer.  We want to learn.  That is why we asked the question.  So, if questioning was the answer back then that showed we wanted to learn... questioning can be the answer again.  Facilitate questioning... encourage it!  That is how students learn to think.
  What are your thoughts?  What are your questions?  I would like to know.  I would like to learn!  Thank you.
1 Comment
    Bookmark and Share

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    Jodi Desautels

         Jodi Desautels is a wife and mother.  She is a life-long learner, educator, author, illustrator, crafter, creator, and photographer.  She lives by two rules:  "The Golden Rule" and "Live. Laugh. Love."

    Picture

    Archives

    May 2017
    February 2015
    January 2015
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013

     

    powered by free-ebooks.net

    Categories

    All
    2015
    21st Century Classroom
    50 States
    5 Helpful Strategies
    Abcs
    Abilities
    Acronym
    Activity
    Activity Sheet
    Adults And Children
    Alexandra Bryan
    Algebraic Exponents
    Ali Dent
    All Abilities
    Alphabet
    Alzheimer's Disease
    Amazon
    Amazon Associates
    And Two
    Andy Griffith Show
    Angie Harris
    Anti-bullying
    Apple
    Art Classes
    Article
    Attitude
    Author
    Author Interviews
    Author Lorieen Henry
    Authors
    Award
    Awe Of Learning
    Back To School
    Basic Skills
    Bb Bag
    Bees
    Beginning Letter
    Beginning Sounds
    Beginning Sounds Activity
    Be Great
    Be Great!
    Believe
    Better Serve You
    Better Student
    Betty-jo
    Beverley Hoyle
    Binder Covers
    Blog
    Blogging
    Book Club
    Book Promotions
    Book Report
    Book Report Organization Questions
    Book Review
    Books
    Books By Jodi Desautels
    Boring
    Brain Food
    Bring Students And Author Together
    Bring Students And Illustrators Together
    Bullying Awareness
    Bullying Prevention
    Busy Day
    Can Be Modified
    Candice Simpson
    Catchy Tune
    Celebrate Differences
    Center Activity
    Cheerleaders
    Chicka Chicka Boom Boom
    Children's Books
    Children's Counselor
    Christmas
    Clarinda Cloud
    Clarinda Cloud
    Clarinda Cloud Activity Book
    Clarinda Cloud Name Tags
    Classroom Teacher
    Clipart
    Coloring
    Colors
    Common Core
    Common Core Poem
    Common Core State Standards Initiative
    Competition
    Composite Numbers
    Concept Book
    Confidence
    Contact Me
    Contest
    Controversy
    Counting
    Craft
    Create Space
    Creative Thinking
    Creativity
    Critical Thinking
    Cross Curricular
    Cultures
    Curriculum
    Customized Educational Materials
    Daily Homework Log
    Daycare
    Daycares
    Deborah Heal
    Dennis Higgins
    Depicting The Problem
    Descriptions
    Desire To Learn
    Determination
    Difference
    Differentiated Instruction
    Dimentia
    Dinosaur
    Disabilities
    Distance Learning
    Dividing Exponents
    Division
    Drawing
    Dumbing Down
    Dumbing Down Society
    Duo Education
    Duo Education Producation
    DUO Inspirations
    Duo Learning
    Ebooks
    Education
    Educational
    Educational Children's Books
    Educational Controversy
    Educational Excellence
    Educational Materials
    Educational Needs
    Educational Posters
    Educational Posters
    Educational Service
    Educational Standards
    Educational Value
    Education Blog
    Educators
    Effective Problem Solving Strategy
    Effects Of Common Core
    Elearning
    Elearning
    Elementary Guidance Counselors
    Elementary School
    Elementary Teachers
    Empowered
    Encourage Learning
    English
    English As A Second Language
    English-language-learners
    Esl
    Exercise
    Exploration
    Fables
    Facilitate Learning
    Factor List
    Factors
    Family
    Feelings
    Fill In
    Fine Motor Skills
    Focus
    Fractions
    Free
    Freedom
    Free On Kindle
    Free Webinars
    Free Writing
    Fun
    Fun Fact Of The Week
    Fun & Friendly Assignment
    Gcf
    Getting To Know You Questions
    GIMP
    Give
    Giveaway
    Glenn Beck
    Goal Card
    Goals
    Golden Rule
    Grades 3-6
    Grammar
    Grammar-rule
    Great Educational Experience
    Greatest Common Factors
    Great Reviews
    Great Teacher
    Great Teachers
    Guess
    Guest Blogger
    Happy New Year
    Helpful Learning Tool
    Hidden Images
    Higher Drop Out Rate
    Higher Level Of Thinking
    Higher Order Thinking
    Holistic Teaching
    Homeschoolers
    Homework
    Huffington Post
    Humor
    Illustrating
    Illustrator Interviews
    Illustrators
    Imagination
    Importance Of Word Choice
    Individualized
    Individualized Learning
    Individualized Learning Plan
    Individualized Plan
    Individualized Plan To Succeed
    Informal Assessment
    Ingrid Hall
    Inspiration
    Inspirational
    Inspired
    Interactive Ebooks
    Interest In Children And Their Education
    Introduction
    Is Knowledge Power
    Issy
    Jackie Williams
    Jam With Jodi Desautels
    Jim Rohn
    Jodi Desautels
    Johnny's Adventure Makes Reading Fun
    Joyce Mitchell
    Keynote
    Kidtales
    Kindergarten
    Kindle
    Knowledge
    Language
    Language Arts
    Lcm
    Learn
    Learnalltheway
    Learning
    Learning Needs
    Learning Page
    Learning Sheet
    Learning Styles
    Learning The Alphabet
    Learning The Numbers
    Least Common Multiples
    Leibster Award
    Lesson
    Lesson Adaptation
    Lesson Idea
    Lesson Modification
    Letter Recognition
    Letters
    Librarians
    Library
    Library Classes
    Life Long Learner
    Life-long Learner
    Lisa Orchard
    Literacy
    Literacy Classes
    Literacy Problems
    Literacy Rates
    Little Helpers
    Looks Right
    Lowercase Letters
    March Marketing Marvel
    Match Uppercase And Lowercase Letters
    Math
    Math Poster
    Math Skills
    Math Standards
    Math Trick
    Math Tutoring
    Mazes
    Meaningful Instruction
    Meeting Individual Learning Needs
    Merry Christmas
    Message
    Mixed Multiplication Practice
    Mixed Multiplication Quiz
    Monthly Newsletter
    Morning Work
    Mother's Day Giveaway
    Motivation
    Multiple Intelligences
    Multiplication
    Multiplication Facts Practice
    Name Tags
    Nanowrimo
    National Math Bee
    Natural Learning
    Nbc Today
    Networking
    New Page
    New Skill
    Nouns
    Offering For Schools
    Online Book Club
    Online Learning
    Online Tutoring
    Online Tutoring Service
    Opinion
    Optimize
    Order Of Operations
    Order Of Operations Explanation
    Organization
    Parent
    Parenting
    Passion For Education
    Pat Calfee
    PEMDAS
    Photography
    Pictures As Cues
    Picture Walk
    Plastic Forks
    Plastic Spoons
    Plasticware Alphabet Game
    Politician
    Politics
    Polls
    Powerpoint
    Power Point
    Prereading
    Pre-reading
    Preschool
    Preschools
    Prime Numbers
    Problem Of The Day
    Problem Of The Week
    Problem Solving
    Program
    Project
    Promote DUO Education
    Questioning
    Question Of The Week
    Questions
    Quiz
    Quotes
    Read An Ebook Week
    Reading
    Reading Help
    Reading Motivation
    Reading Program
    Reading Strategy
    Reading Tutoring
    Recycle
    Resource
    Resources
    Responsibility
    Re-use
    Reviews
    Rhyming
    Sample Binder Covers
    Sandra Portman
    Sarah Armstrong
    Sarah Bowman
    School Counselors
    School Guidance Counselors
    School Visit
    Science
    Screen Recording
    Self-education
    Shapes
    Share
    Share And Win Party
    Sharing Feelings
    Sherry Ellis
    Silly Nouns
    Simulated Baseball Game
    Site Changes
    Site Transformation
    Sizes
    Small Group
    Smooth-transitions
    Snowmen
    Songs
    Spatial
    Spelling
    Spiral-gradient
    Spokescloud
    S Stocking Activity
    Standards
    Still-learning-something-new
    Story Starters
    Story-starters
    Storyteller's Tale
    Strategies
    Strategy
    Student
    Student Interest Questions
    Students
    Study Skills
    Study Skills Tutoring
    Successful Teaching Practices Around The World
    Summer Reading Spectacular
    Summer Time
    Summer Time Learning
    Summertime Learning
    Super Spies Mystery/Thriller Series
    Support
    Susan Wingate
    Synonyms
    Tangram
    Teach
    Teach A Man To Fish
    Teacher Appreciation
    Teachers Making A Difference
    Teaching
    Teaching About Goal Setting
    Teaching Aid
    Teaching People How To Think
    Teaching Tips
    Teaching Tool
    Team
    Texting
    Texting Abbreviations
    Texting Terms
    Thank You
    The Blaze Tv
    The Game Room
    Themes
    The Six Traits Of Writing
    The Super Spies
    The Super Spies And The Cat Lady Killer
    The Super Spies And The High School Bomber
    Thinking Creatively
    Thinking For Yourself
    Time And Again
    To
    Too
    Tournament
    Tracing
    Transformation
    Transitions
    Treasure Hunt
    Trying
    Tutorial
    Tutoring
    Tutoring Services
    Unclaimed Legacy
    Units
    Uppercase Letters
    Value Of Individuality
    Value Of Thinking For Yourself
    Various Ages
    Vermont
    Videos
    Virginia Wright
    Visual
    Vocabulary
    Water Cycle
    Webinar
    Webinar Series
    Webinars For Authors And Readers
    Weekly Bookclub Webinar
    Wendy Nystrom
    When Do I Use Too?
    Whole Group
    Whole Group Activity
    Win
    Word Bank
    Word Choice
    Wordless Book
    Word Of The Week
    Word Recognition
    Words
    Word Search
    Work Sheet
    Writing
    Writing Prompt
    Writing Prompt
    Writing Strategies
    Writing Tutoring
    Www.AuthorJodiDesautels.com
    Www.ClarindaCloud.com
    Www.ClarindaCloud.com
    Www.DUOEducation.com

    RSS Feed

A Path to a Brighter Future